In the annals of Irish history, our gaze often turned eastward to continental Europe, West to the Americas, or southward to the Mediterranean. However, a fascinating chapter of Irish migration and influence lies hidden in the frigid waters of the North Atlantic.
Iceland, that island of fire and ice, bears an Irish imprint that dates back to its earliest days of human habitation. There was a time that Irish people migrated in solid numbers to Iceland.
The Papar: Ireland’s Pioneering Explorers
Long before the Vikings set foot on Icelandic shores, Irish monks known as the Papar had already established a presence on the island. These intrepid spiritual seekers, driven by a desire for solitude and uninterrupted devotion, braved the harsh North Atlantic to find sanctuary in Iceland’s remote landscapes. The Papar left behind more than just footprints.
When Norse settlers arrived in Iceland around 874 AD, they discovered tangible evidence of these earlier Irish inhabitants. Books, bells, and other artifacts spoke of a culture steeped in learning and faith, painting a picture of these pioneering Irish explorers. It’s important to note that the evidence for the Papar is limited and often debated among historians. But here’s what we think we know.
Some place names in Iceland, such as Papey (Monks’ Island), point to an Irish monastic presence.
Books
While no actual books from the Papar have been found in Iceland, early Norse sources mention finding Irish books that today we think were illuminated manuscripts or prayer books. The most notable reference comes from the Íslendingabók (Book of Icelanders) written by Ari Þorgilsson around 1122-1133 AD. Iceland, that island of fire and ice, bears an Irish imprint that dates back to its earliest days of human habitation. There was a time that Irish people migrated in solid numbers to Iceland.
Bells
Hand bells were used by the Papar for calls to prayer or during religious ceremonies. Archaeological excavations have uncovered bell fragments on Icelandic sites. Definitively linking these to the Papar is not completely certain as they could also have belonged to later Christian settlers. However they make a pretty good case for early Irish settlers. There are other artefacts found: Crosses, croziers (staff carried by bishops), or other religious items that were known to be used by the Papar.
And fascinatingly, some place names in Iceland, such as Papey (Monks’ Island), point to an Irish monastic presence. And, some circular stone structures have been found in Iceland that resemble early Irish Christian hermitages. However, their origins are subjects of ongoing debate among archaeologists. As for written evidence, it comes from later Norse sources, particularly the Íslendingabók and Landnámabók (Book of Settlements). These texts mention the presence of Irish monks when the Norse arrived. This can be wildly fascinating to Irish people.
Irish Migration: The Norse Arrival and Cultural Fusion
The arrival of Norse settlers in the late 9th century marked the beginning of a new era for Iceland – one that would be profoundly shaped by Irish influence. Far from erasing the Irish presence, the Norse integration with the existing Irish elements created a unique cultural tapestry. Many Norse settlers took Irish women as wives or brought them to Iceland as slaves. This practice led to a significant blending of cultures and genetic heritage, the effects of which are still evident today.
Irish Migration: Women in Early Iceland
During the Norse settlement of Iceland, which began around 874 AD, it was common for Norse men to bring women from the British Isles, particularly Ireland and Scotland, to Iceland. This practice occurred for several reasons. The initial wave of settlers to Iceland was predominantly male, creating a shortage of women. And, many Irish women were taken as slaves or captives during Viking raids on Ireland. But it could have also been less violent. Some relationships may have formed through trade connections or political alliances between Norse settlers and Irish nobility. Fascinatingly, Icelandic sagas, while not always historically accurate, often mention Irish women among the early settlers.
Many Norse settlers took Irish women as wives or brought them to Iceland as slaves.
For example, the Laxdæla saga tells of Melkorka, an Irish princess taken as a slave who became the mother of a prominent Icelandic chieftain. Interestingly, some Icelandic place names have Irish origins, suggesting the influence of Irish settlers, including women. Modern genetic studies have provided strong evidence for the significant presence of Irish women in early Iceland due to Irish migration.
A 2001 study by Agnar Helgason et al. found that 63% of early Icelandic maternal lineages had Celtic (Irish or Scottish) origins. In contrast, only about 20% of male lineages show Celtic origins, supporting the narrative of Norse men bringing Celtic women to Iceland. Studies of autosomal DNA (inherited from both parents) confirm a significant Celtic contribution to the Icelandic gene pool.
Cultural Impact of Irish Migration
The presence of Irish women in early Iceland likely had several cultural impacts. Some linguists argue that certain features of Icelandic, such as the preservation of the dental fricatives (th-sounds), may have been influenced by the Irish language. And some elements of Icelandic folklore show similarities to Irish traditions, possibly due to the influence of Irish women.
A Shared Heritage
The story of the Irish in Iceland is more than just a historical curiosity. It represents a shared heritage that binds our two island nations across centuries and vast stretches of ocean. From the solitary Papar seeking spiritual solace to the Irish women who helped shape Iceland’s early society, the Irish-Icelandic connection is a testament to the enduring impact of cultural exchange and human migration.
As we continue to uncover the depths of this connection through historical research and genetic studies, we gain a richer understanding of our own history and the complex tapestry of European heritage. The Irish- Icelandic link serves as a reminder that even in the most seemingly remote corners of the world, we may find echoes of home.
If you want more exciting stories, be sure to purchase the 2025 Old Moore’s Almanac for predictions, articles, and everything Ireland!
